Amelia Island has no shortage of places to enjoy a well-made drink, but a few bars stand out for their attention to craft. From inventive cocktails with a playful twist to timeless classics prepared with care, these are the spots worth seeking out for a quality pour.
Step inside The Principal’s Office, a vintage-inspired bar set in a former elementary school dating back to 1886.
The historic backdrop makes every cocktail feel like part of a story, blending charm, hospitality, and a dash of nostalgia. The menu leans into its schoolhouse theme with playful creations like the spicy-yet-refreshing Smarty Pants or the inventive Lunch Box.
Paired with seasonal bites, it’s proof that being “sent to the Principal’s Office” can be the highlight of your night.
Recess – A bright and refreshing mix of vodka, Aperol, citrus, blueberries, and basil, this cocktail is playful yet sophisticated. It’s like summer in a glass.
Class Act – Bourbon lovers will appreciate this silky, coconut fat–washed creation layered with falernum and toasted coconut bitters for a tropical twist.
Smarty Pants – A lively pisco cocktail with cucumber, jalapeño, and citrus, offering the perfect balance of fresh, spicy, and crisp.
Lunchbox – Equal parts quirky and elegant, this gin-based drink blends carrot and ginger juice with a splash of ginger beer for a one-of-a-kind flavor.
Beauty School Dropout – Tequila meets ancho chile and citrus, topped with a pomegranate-orange foam. It’s colorful, bold, and unforgettable.
Live Music Thursdays – Local musicians set the mood every Thursday from 5–8 pm.
Daily Happy Hour – Specials on drinks from 4–6 pm each day.
Cocktail Classes – Hands-on mixology sessions offered Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday at 1 pm and 2 pm.
Private Events – Available year-round for parties, gatherings, and special occasions
914 Atlantic Ave, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034
Hidden within the historic Florida House Inn & Courtyard, The Mermaid Bar offers a cozy retreat with a touch of whimsy.
Its menu of mermaid-inspired cocktails from the playful Mermaid Slap to the colorful Pink Mermaid martini turns each glass into a little piece of art.
When available, seasonal appetizers add the perfect pairing, making this tucked-away spot a charming escape for cocktail lovers.
Mermaid Slap – A vibrant, tropical rum punch splashed with citrus and garnished playfully with a Swedish Fish. Fun, colorful, and unmistakably mermaid-themed.
Pink Mermaid – Fruity and refreshing, this vodka cocktail layers pomegranate, peach, and cranberry for a sweet coastal twist.
The Dirty Dina – Dessert in a glass, this martini combines chocolate and coffee liqueurs with a creamy finish and cocoa rim.
The Savage – A bold tequila cocktail with muddled jalapeño, basil, lime, and honey syrup, delivering a fiery yet balanced sip.
The Rocket – Bourbon meets elderflower and cherry, lifted with bitters and citrus, for a sophisticated, spirit-forward option.
For a taste of Mexico with a modern twist, Mezcal delivers both atmosphere and artistry.
Specializing in mezcal tequila’s smokier, more complex cousin, the bar highlights the spirit’s versatility through an inventive cocktail list. From the sweet, floral notes of the Flora de Oaxaca to the bold kick of the Lilia margarita, each drink is crafted to let mezcal’s character shine.
Pair your cocktail with authentic Mexican fare indoors or linger on the spacious patio for a laid-back, flavorful evening.
Flora de Oaxaca – A floral-meets-smoky sip that blends mezcal with hibiscus, citrus, and ancho chile for a refreshing yet complex flavor.
Luna Picante – Sweet pineapple and lime meet jalapeño heat in this bold cocktail that balances tropical notes with a spicy finish.
Espíritu – Light and herbaceous, this mix of mezcal, cucumber, and mint offers a crisp, garden-fresh twist perfect for warm evenings.
Antigua – A rich blend of mezcal, coffee liqueur, ancho chile, and chocolate bitters, creating a smoky, slightly sweet indulgence.
Mezcarindo – Tangy tamarind and citrus pair with mezcal and ancho chile for a bold, tropical cocktail with a unique edge.
302 Centre St, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034
Tucked into the heart of downtown Fernandina Beach, The Decantery is Amelia Island’s go-to spot for an evening of refined sipping. The lounge blends elegance with comfort, think plush seating, warm lighting, and a relaxed, intimate atmosphere.
Behind the bar, cocktails range from a silky espresso martini to a dramatic smoked Old Fashioned, each crafted with style and substance.
Pair your drink with a charcuterie board or a decadent dessert, and you’ve got the perfect recipe for winding down after a day by the coast.
Smoked “Lew” Old Fashioned
A dramatic twist on the classic: the drink is smoked tableside, adding aroma and depth that linger through each sip.
Amelia Island Tea
A refreshing, tea-inspired cocktail that blends subtle sweetness with citrus notes — ideal for sipping on a warm evening.
Lavender Kiss
Delicate and floral, this vibrant cocktail is served in a coupe and balances lavender character without being overly sweet.
Espresso Martini
Smooth and bold, this cocktail combines rich espresso with a silky finish — perfect as a nightcap or post-dinner treat.
Casa Rosada / Cayenne Mango Margarita (or House-Twist Margarita)
A vibrant twist on margarita flavor, this version brings tropical mango or citrus spice balance, giving the classic new character.
117 Centre Street, Fernandina Beach, FL
For a cocktail with a touch of sophistication, head to The Lobby Bar at The Ritz-Carlton, Amelia Island.
This elegant lounge pairs handcrafted drinks with a refined coastal setting, complete with ocean views and live music on select evenings.
Signature cocktails highlight small-batch spirits and fresh ingredients, making it an ideal spot for a romantic evening or an upscale night out.
Smoked Old Fashioned
A bold twist on the classic, enhanced with aromatic smoke for depth and drama.
House-Infused Bourbon
Daily infusions highlight flavors like spice or citrus, offering a unique pour each visit.
Seasonal Cocktail
Rotating creations feature fresh, local ingredients for a drink that feels tied to the island.
Reimagined Classics
Martinis, Manhattans, and Negronis are elevated with small-batch spirits and refined garnishes.
Sparkling Selection
Effervescent cocktails with Champagne or sparkling wine add a celebratory coastal flair.
Live Music Nights – Enjoy local musicians performing in the lounge on select evenings.
“First Call” Bourbon Ritual – A daily unveiling of house-infused bourbon blends crafted by the bartenders.
Special Performances – Occasional concerts and guest acts, such as bands and seasonal showcases.
117 Centre Street, Fernandina Beach, FL
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
